Most of us realize that fasting isn’t a way to earn extra credit points with God by proving our willingness to deprive ourselves; as if God wanted to be entertained by our misery. Fasting isn’t a version of being a petulant child threatening to hold our breath (i.e., not eat) until our heavenly father bends to our will.
But there is a big difference between knowing what fasting isn’t (i.e., debunking misconceptions) and knowing how fasting fosters spiritual growth. If we are more prone to the temptation of over-restricting than over-eating, this difference can be a vitally important point of reflection.
Fasting in Its Original Context
Let’s start with a historical observation. When fasting emerged as a spiritual practice, people had a very different relationship with food. The food-related cultural epidemic was famine, not obesity. For most of human history there has been a world-wide caloric deficit, not excess. There were not enough calories (i.e., food) to sustain the human population. People didn’t long to be thin; they hoped to be full. On this point, our era is unique.
Why does that matter? Well, in our day, we tend to associate fasting with dieting. That is logical, but it distorts what fasting, as a spiritual discipline, is about. In an era when there was frequently not enough food for the general population, fasting was a form of trust and sacrifice.
- Trust: When someone finished fasting there was no promise of a full pantry. The markets were not so bountiful with food that people were selective about the freshest melons and unsmashed bread.
- Sacrifice: Forgoing a meal meant there would be a meal for others. In an ear of inadequate food supply, food consumption felt more like sports; one person winning (i.e., eating) meant someone else was losing.
Seeing this allows us to better understand the sin of gluttony as an expression of selfishness, while today we tend to only think of gluttony as contributing to obesity or other health problems. In an era where there was not enough food, over-eating put others at risk.
Leaving the example about gluttony and returning to the subject of fasting, we begin to see that fasting was about more (not less) than setting aside time that would have been otherwise spent eating a meal for prayer. Fasting was a deep expression of trust in God (i.e., fulfilling the First Great Commandment) and a means of caring for people (i.e., fulfilling the Second Great Commandment).
From Then to Now
In light of this, let’s return to the modern practice of fasting. Particularly, let’s consider the practice of fasting for individuals for whom abstaining from food would be unhealthy.
- Question: If I struggle with over-restricting (i.e., anorexia or bulimia) or if abstaining from food has other health risks for me (i.e., pregnancy or diabetes), how does this history of food and fasting impact the way I engage this spiritual discipline?
We begin to see that being hungry was never the point. The point was to intentionally focus a season of your life on finding ways to deepen your trust in God and sacrifice for others. This is why fasting doesn’t have to be about food. Foregoing food was one way – a way that had high cultural relevance – to practice fasting.
A Process of Application
I’ll offer a four step process to identifying what God-honoring fasting looks like for you if over-restricting has been more of a struggle in your life than over-eating.
First, care for your body. God is not against your body. When we over-restrict, it is often because we have a strong dislike for our body. It could be easy to interpret the discipline of fasting as God agreeing with our dislike and calling upon us to further punish ourselves. That is not true. God made your body, said it was good, and wants you to steward the body he entrusted to you with care.
Second, grow in trust for God. God is good, and God is for you. Therefore, you can trust him and following him will not lead to self-destructive practices. This begs the question, “What are you believing or pursuing that would lead you to engage in harmful practices?” These practices might include: weighing multiple times per day, time calculating calories, excessive exercise, ruminating on your body image, or ruminating on guilt about your eating patterns. Fasting, that deepened your trust in God as being good and for you, would replace these habits (instead of forgoing meals) with prayer. God would be delighted to have you come to him for conversation rather than harm yourself in these ways.
Third, grow in care for people. God wants to see your relationships with others to be more authentic, vulnerable, and a source of mutual care. Whatever time and emotional bandwidth the second point creates, find ways to invest that in both prayer and caring for others.
- Did you choose to fast from social media, Pinterest, or other types of media that cause you to idealize particular body images or lifestyles? Invest that time in prayer and calling friends to encourage them.
- Did you choose to fast from shopping to cope with discontentment because appearance or status was too important for you? Invest those funds in ministries to at-risk in your community and ask the leaders of that ministry how you can be praying for them.
- Did you choose to fast from multitasking as a means of performance-based approval seeking? Identify the areas of where contentment is more God-honoring and devote the time you would have spent pursuing enslaving-excellence to pray or encourage others.
Fourth, allow this type of fasting to become a lifestyle. Once we realize that God’s call to spiritual disciplines is for our growth and good, we begin to realize that a discipline like fasting is meant to be more of a lifestyle than a short-lived New Year’s resolution. Begin to view fasting as a means of God freeing you from the things that Satan would use to enslave you. Find ways to cooperate with that freedom on a regular basis. Grow in your trust for God and care for others as you do.
Begin to view fasting as a means of God freeing you from the things that Satan would use to enslave you. Find ways to cooperate with that freedom on a regular basis. Share on X