At the 2025 Called to Counsel preconference I am honored to join with Jonathan Holmes, Dwayne Bond, and Shauna Van Dyke to provide the preconference on “Counseling the Attributes of God.” We will be working our way through Lamentations 3:21-26 and each reflecting on the counseling implications for one of the attributes of God found in this passage.
- Session 1: Jonathan Holmes on God’s Love
- Session 2: Brad Hambrick on God’s Mercy
- Session 3: Shauna Van Dyke on God’s Faithfulness
- Session 4: Dwayne Bond on God’s Goodness
As a part of my preconference session, I will use a case (see below) to help participants grapple with the counseling implications of God’s mercy. I am providing the case study in advance in case you want to begin reflecting on how you might counsel Ava about the mercy of God in light of her family challenges.
Case Study *
Ava’s Confusion about Mercy
* This is fictional case study and not the real life events of an actual person.
Ava grew up in a family that took the bronze at the dysfunctional family Olympics. Plenty of other families were more dysfunctional than hers, but her family belonged on the podium.
Ava’s father was selfish. His friends, hobbies, and work came first. This meant her father was often away from home and that the responsibility to be the sole manager of the family was forced on mom. Even though dad had a good job, dad spent so much on his interests, that there was rarely money for anything beyond Ava and her brother’s basic needs. Ava was frequently embarrassed at the things she couldn’t do (i.e., class trips or extracurricular activities) or have (i.e., fashionable clothes) that were normal for her friends and reasonable for their family’s status.
Ava’s mother was fearful-controlling. She was never sure what might upset her husband, so she set exceedingly high standards for Ava and her brother. Peace mattered most to Ava’s mom. The family didn’t know when dad would change the plans, so everyone had to remain highly adaptable. This meant making personal plans with her friends was called “selfish” by mom. As a result, Ava seemed aloof and unreliable to her friends. Mom used guilt and excessive emotional appeals to maintain control of Ava and her brother. If Ava’s father was entitled, her mother was reactive. Ava couldn’t rely on her father and didn’t trust her mother.
Ava’s parents argued frequently and intensely. As best Ava could tell, her dad was usually more at fault, and he definitely didn’t fight fair. Whenever there was an argument, her dad was going to win. When her father was upset, he was loud, unrelenting, and cutting. Ava heard her father yell many things she knew were not true. Ava heard mom say equally false things to try to keep the peace. Oddly, every morning after one of these arguments, breakfast was served and everyone began their day as if nothing happened. She wondered if this faux peace was some version of what the Bible meant by God’s mercies being new every morning (Lamentations 3:22-23).
Ava’s older brother decided rules didn’t matter. If he was going to be punished by living in a chaotic home, he might as well have as much fun as he could to make up for it. Her brother was popular in the party scene at school, and when Ava wasn’t willing to be part of that crowd, he mocked her. A senior publicly demeaning a freshman is hard enough, but if that senior is your big brother, who should be a source of protection, it is even worse. At home, the trouble her brother got into only provoked more conflict between Ava’s parents. Because her brother was undependable, the expectations for Ava to be the peacekeeper increased even more. Is this what Jesus meant by “blessed are the peacemakers (Matt 5:9)”?
Eventually, Ava began to feel as if life was unfair, as if there was no sense of order. She was always asked to give mercy to others but never received mercy or understanding in return. In an unfair world, Ava did the thing it makes sense to do – she began to live as if there were no rules. If there are no rules, then why live to avoid consequences? It seemed to be working for her brother, maybe it would work for her.
Ava’s conscience was strong enough that it was hard for her to be too bad. She went to a couple of parties, drank a little, and blew off studying so her GPA dropped. The guilt and regret she felt far outweighed the fun she had. Ava was too good at being good to enjoy being bad. It felt so unfair that her conscience wouldn’t let her enjoy being bad, and her family chaos made it so hard to enjoy life when she was being good.
To make matters worse, her experimentation with rebellion came at just the wrong time. Her falling GPA cost her the opportunity to go to her first-choice college. When her Christians friends raised concerns about her choices, Ava had dismissed them and damaged those friendships. Ava wasn’t good at lying, so she got her new friends in trouble when she couldn’t cover up for their parties. Several of her new friends got in trouble because of that and she was ostracized by them. Ava felt more alone and misunderstood than ever.
Ava’s getting in trouble made her parents flip out. Having Ava fail at her family role – peacekeeper – was unacceptable, not because it was concerning for Ava, but because it was inconvenient for the family. Now Ava was being treated like her choices were even worse than her brother’s. Both the consequences and the shame from her parents were more intense than anything her brother faced.
Ava was mature enough in her faith that, when she began to listen to her conscience again, she knew she should think about her situation in “a God-centered way.” But that only made her more confused and angrier. Ava felt the sin of her parents and brother intensely. Ava carried the guilt for her own sin. She could hardly bear disappointing her parents, much less God. But God seemed silent toward those who sinned against her but like he had a megaphone when she sinned against him. That made God feel as unfair and arbitrary as her parents.
Ava comes to you angry (secondary emotion) and hurt (primary emotion), because Ava knows you’re a Christian and she values her faith. Ava directly raises questions about the mercy of God. Why does God’s mercy seem so one-sided and biased? Ava says God’s mercy feels like a hoax that cripples those who try to be good and reinforces the oppression of the weak.
Where do you begin with Ava? How do approach her questions regarding God’s character? How does her personal and family history impact the way you engage her question about God’s mercy?
Here is a printable 2-page PDF of this case study.
Event Information
If you are able to join us, here is the information about the Called to Counsel conference hosted by the Association of Biblical Counselors.
Called to Counseling Conference
Lcation: Doxology Bible Church
Address: 4805 Arborlawn Dr. Fort Worth, TX 76109
Dates: May 1-3, 2025
Register Here