It can be easy to equate “positive” as “good” and “negative” as “bad.” After all, being positive and encouraging is more emotionally pleasant than being negative and critical. But Scripture calls us to do unpleasant things that require making distinctions between truth and error, moral and immoral, worthwhile and fruitless. For this reason, this renewed call for a positive vision for biblical counseling is not meant to disparage critical assessment.
However, too much of any good thing (like critical assessment) becomes a distraction from the most important things. In recent years, biblical counseling has been moving increasingly in this direction. Attempts to define the “purest of all forms of biblical counseling” and to disparage approaches deemed less pure have become too central in our public and private conversations. It is time to refocus.
Why? When criticism becomes our dominant posture, it is poor stewardship of the time God has given us to make a difference with the hope of the gospel and the truth of Scripture so that people are made into more holy and more whole members of God’s family, the church.
What Is this Renewed Call?
Simply put: be excellent at what God has called you to do. If you are reading this article, you love biblical counseling. Each one of us has a unique context and set of gifts through which God intends to do his work (Rom. 12:4-8, I Pet. 4:10-11).
- Are you a church member and good friend? Don’t be so distracted by the drama you read on the internet that you lose sight of caring for those close to you. Your friends need you to be fully present with them.
- Are you a lay counselor? Don’t be discouraged by differences between biblical counseling leaders you respect; instead glean from each of them what helps you faithfully care for the people in front of you. If you do, your counselees will be better served.
- Are you a pastor or ministry leader? Don’t become fearful about being criticized if you use the wrong “buzz word of the month” but instead use the full breadth of biblical counseling resources available to shepherd your congregation. Your church will be thankful.
- Are you a professor of biblical counseling? Don’t teach controversy in a way that leads your students into either pride or timidity. Instead, teach your students to “eat the fish and spit out the bones” without feeling compelled to attack other fishers of men. Your students will be better – both in character and ministry – if you do.
- Are you a professional counselor? Don’t fall into the mindset of believing you cannot be missional in your setting but instead continue to challenge yourself to find as many ways as possible to be a faithful ambassador of Christ within the limits of licensure. We need more mission-minded, licensed counselors.
My biggest concern regarding these years of hyper-negativity is this: fear of public criticism will stifle creativity in the continued development of biblical counseling. After a mere 55 years, biblical counseling has not arrived. We have much work to do in refining our craft. This is not the time to allow a spirit of suspicion and fear of criticism to stifle the continued growth God wants to develop in and through the biblical counseling movement.
My biggest concern regarding these years of hyper-negativity is this: fear of public criticism will stifle creativity in the continued development of biblical counseling. Share on XThe Danger of Excessive Negativity
It is easy to fall into the trap of assuming, “If we can prove how everyone else is wrong, then we must be right.” We may accurately spot the weakness in what 20 other people think but that doesn’t necessarily make our personal approach any stronger. A predominantly critical approach fails to embrace the reality that God always has and always will work through imperfect people who are perpetually learning and growing (I Tim. 1:15-16).
This call to a renewed, positive vision of biblical counseling is to call for biblical counselor to return our focus to cultivating excellence in our sphere of ministry rather than being preoccupied with critiquing others. God’s church, and the biblical counseling movement, will be stronger if this shift happens.
Are You with Me?
If not, that saddens me. You are not my enemy. I pray God blesses your work. Know I read some (not all) of your critiques and each time I do, I ask myself, “What can I learn from this?” I believe the best about your intentions. You want to protect something we both value. But I also believe your efforts frequently show significant bias and are uncharitable. For that reason, I am recommending that my fellow brothers and sisters in Christ to devote less time to reading and responding to your ongoing criticisms.
If so, simply be excellent at the good work God has called you to do. You are my co-laborers. I pray God blesses your work. I look forward to seeing the fresh applications and expressions of biblical counseling you develop. Always be humble and willing to learn, but do not allow fear of criticism to become a distraction. As you do fresh work, share it with the church. Allow it to be multiplied through other counselors and replicated in other churches. That is why biblical counseling began. Let us not lose sight of our calling or grow weary in doing good (Gal. 6:9).
- Action Step 1 (Reclaim Time) – When you see comments from chronically critical individuals or organizations, either ignore it or simply reply with something like, “There is too much positive work to be done not to heed II Timothy 2:23-24, Proverbs 26:4, or Romans 14:1.” These passages are about not engaging fruitless arguments and not being quarrelsome.
- Action Step 2 (Invest Time) – When you see positive developments in biblical counseling, publicly affirm them. As Romans 13:7 teaches, give honor to whom honor is due. In the model of Ephesians 4:22-24, let us put off excessive negativity by putting on public affirmation.
People are not confused. Ample time has been spent articulating our differences. It is time to focus on developing our respective approaches and allow the fruit of our labor to be the arbiter of our differences.
These two steps represent a way to renew our collective focus on cultivating models of care that enhance the depth and breadth of counseling provided in and alongside the church. As we do, may God be honored and his people edified by our words to counselees and about our fellow counselors.
What’s Next?
I’m excited to find out. Ponder with me – what might God do in and through his people if we reclaimed the time given to internal conflicts and invested that time in cultivating the work of biblical counseling? Let’s find out!
What might God do in and through his people if we reclaimed the time given to internal conflicts and invested that time in cultivating the work of biblical counseling? Let’s find out! Share on X