The Biblical Counseling Coalition recently posted a 10 minute conversation with David Powlison where he considers how a Christian should interact with psychology. In the video below Powlison examines six different ways the term psychology can be used. In this post, I would like continue his conversation.
David Powlison – Is Biblical Counseling For or Against Psychology? from Biblical Counseling Coalition on Vimeo.
Below is a summary of Powlison’s six uses of psychology as he wrote them in Psychology and Christianity: Four Views edited by Eric Johnson and Stanton Jones (2000, Intervarsity Press). I will embed my reflections as indented paragraphs under these definitions. I will use the simple analogy of “connecting the dots” to illustrate Powlison’s points.
I will provide one preface thought. I find these six definitions very useful, even if they are necessarily technical. It is easy to use the same word to talk about different things and create confusion. I believe this often happens in the conversation about psychology and theology. That is why these kinds of distinctions are needed.
If we talk about 'psychologies' instead of 'psychology,' we'll have a more fruitful conversation. Share on X1. Psychology per se: Refers to the way people actually live. It is the “facts” that a psychological theory must explain. It is “simply ‘you,’ a being who functions psychologically (p. 198).”
“There are dots to connect.” It can be tempting for some to treat the word “psychology” like the word “unicorn.” A word that everyone understands, but also knows doesn’t really exist. People, relationships, emotions, maturational development, aptitude, intelligence, and group dynamics are real things. Psychology, therefore, should be recognized as more than the modern equivalent of Greek mythology.
2. Psychology as Knowledge about Human Functioning: “Refers to many sorts of close observations and descriptions of human psychological functioning, the ‘facts’ noticed and portrayed (p. 199).” This term refers to collected data obtained by research psychologists before any type of order or meaning is intentionally placed on it.
“The dots do make a picture.” We can collect information about people, emotions, and the other things listed above. As a “hard science” we can have “hard facts” about people. This information can be useful. How are people and emotions affected by the absence of sleep? What colors make a product more desirable to consumers? What skill sets or personalities types find particular careers most fulfilling? While this general information can only cautiously be applied to a particular individual, it is useful and a legitimate form of psychological study.
3. Psychology as Competing Philosophy of Life and Theories of Personality: Refers to the “doctrinal core” of a psychology. “Each psychologies’ interpretive system is embodied in a set of standards, against which diagnoses are made and towards which therapies aspire in seeking to alter life into something more worth living. The schema guides counseling conversations towards whatever ‘image’ a human being is meant to be (p. 205).”
“There is a right, biblical picture.” This is where psychology becomes most subjective (largely leaving the realm of science) and most problematic for Christians. It is at this level that psychologies (Powlison’s use of the plural is an excellent point) can be consistent with Scripture, compete with Scripture, or distract from Scripture. A counseling theory will either remind us that we are primarily made in God’s image to glorify God, broken by sin, and able to be redeemed by Christ; or it will define people, problems, and solutions that point to some other source of ultimate hope.
4. Psychology as Psychotherapy: “Counseling practices and strategies designed to facilitate change in belief, behaviors, feelings, attitudes, values, relationships, and the like (p. 210).” This term calls attention to all the methodologies utilized by the counselor.
“Each picture leads to a process.” Meaning leads to action. The same action (i.e., running) can be sparked by different interpretations (i.e., playing chase or being stalked). It is often assumed that if Christian and secular counselors ask people to do the same thing, then their counsel is equally valid. But this neglects that “practical helps” emanate from and reinforce pictures of the human condition. A child who fears being abused may be “effective” at playing chase, but that effectiveness is not healthy. The same can be said for “effective” counseling methodologies that emanate from misguided counseling theories.
5. Psychology as a System of Institutional Arrangements:Refers to the educational systems, accrediting bodies, examining boards, clinics, hospitals, counseling offices, licensing laws, court systems, and referral networks. When an individual looks for a counselor there is a system in place that directs that individual to an “acceptable” or “qualified” counselor.
“Groups and systems form around pictures.” This is why we have political parties. People see the “dots” of various issues a certain way and group themselves accordingly. These groupings have a way of becoming institutionalized. The same is true of musicians, chefs, and offensive coordinators in football. Once these classifications of pictures become refined, then we develop ways of defining who is in and out, and create standards or ranks. These criteria are usually helpful at first for communicating with “the public” and then are regularly challenged as the field grows, expands, and interacts with neighboring areas of study.
6. Psychology as a Mass Ethos: “Psychology in this final sense is the Zeitgeist of a therapeutic society. Terms such as alcoholism and dysfunctionality, a proliferation of syndromes, the explosion of Ritalin and Prozac use, and psychologized legal defense are among the most obvious signposts of the phenomena (p. 217).”
“Pictures move people.” The purpose of psychology is influence. Just like the purpose of art, science, sports, and industry are to influence. We do the things we do because we want to change the world – for love or greed. People respond to pictures. This is why we love stories, illustrations, and metaphors. They give us understanding, meaning, and direction. Ultimately this is why this whole conversation matters.
A Biblical Psychology
Biblical Psychology says that people are meaning-givers because we were created in the image of an intelligent God who wanted us to know Him, enjoy Him, and make Him known. Biblical Psychology says sin entered the world, corrupted our lives, infiltrated our relationships, and created many kinds of suffering. Biblical Psychology says God introduced the cure of the gospel through the life, death, and resurrection of Jesus Christ, and called for the cure to be continually applied as people live in community with one another in the church. Biblical Psychology says that things will not ultimately be made right until Christ returns and the redemption He purchased is fully realized.
I am “for” this kind of “psychology” at all six levels.I want us to know people accurately describe people vividly, help people skillfully, create structures that reinforce a biblical psyhcology, and do all this so well it is compelling to the world around us.
As we grapple with false or incomplete psychologies, may we do so in a way that focuses on winning people rather than winning arguments. The whole goal of biblical counseling is caring for people. We may view these six references for psychology differently. We may assess examples in each category differently. When we do, we should discuss our differences. They matter. But debating our differences should not become more central to our focus than helping people.